The Federal Government Executes Lezmond Mitchell Against Navajo Opposition

For Immediate Release: August 27, 2020
Contact: Krisanne Vaillancourt Murphy at (571) 337-9197 
Website:  Twitter: @CMNEndtheDP

The Federal Government Executes Lezmond Mitchell Against Navajo Opposition

(Washington, DC) On Wednesday evening, the federal government executed Lezmond Mitchell, the only Native American on the federal death row, despite vocal opposition from the Navajo Nation.

“Like the Catholic Church, the Navajo Nation upholds a belief in the sanctity of human life. It is this belief which grounds both traditions’ opposition to the execution of Lezmond Mitchell and the use of capital punishment more broadly,” commented Krisanne Vaillancourt Murphy, Executive Director of Catholic Mobilizing Network, the national Catholic organization working to end the death penalty and promote restorative justice. “As Catholics, we stand with our Native American brothers and sisters in mourning this unnecessary loss of life and attack on human dignity.”

Lezmond Mitchell and his co-defendant, Johnny Orsinger, were convicted in 2003 for the brutal  killing of Alyce Slim, 63, and her 9-year-old granddaughter, Tiffany Lee. The crime was committed on Native American territory, which, under the Federal Death Penalty Act, should have made a murder case subject to Native approval before any death sentence could be sought. Despite this, the federal government pursued a death sentence for Mr. Mitchell, trying him for carjacking resulting in death — a federal offense that did not depend on the crime occurring on tribal land.

The Navajo Nation opposed the death penalty for Mr. Mitchell, as evidenced by clemency appeals made by the president of the Navajo Nation, the Navajo vice president, the Navajo Nation Tribal Council, the National Congress of American Indians, more than a dozen other Native American tribes, and hundreds of individual Native American citizens. 

CMN held a Virtual Prayer Vigil Wednesday afternoon during which hundreds of Catholics and people of goodwill prayed for Mr. Mitchell, his victims, their loved ones, and all those impacted by this act of state-sanctioned violence. A family member of the victims participated in the vigil, which was co-led by Bishop James S. Wall of Gallup, New Mexico — the diocese where Mr. Mitchell’s crime was committed — who also serves as the current Chairman of the USCCB Office of Native American Affairs.

“God is the author and giver of all human life, and we’re called to be good stewards of that life,” the bishop told Catholic News Agency in advance of Mr. Mitchell’s execution. “Humanity cannot allow the violent act of an individual to cause other members of humanity to react in violence.”

The execution of Mr. Mitchell marks the fourth in a string of executions carried out by the Trump Administration amid its relentless campaign to restart the practice of capital punishment after a 17-year hiatus. Three men were executed over the span of four days in July, and the federal execution of Keith Dwayne Nelson is set for Friday, Aug. 28.


Catholic Mobilizing Network is a national organization that mobilizes Catholics and all people of goodwill to value life over death, to end the death penalty, to transform the U.S. criminal justice system from punitive to restorative, and to build capacity in U.S. society to engage in restorative practices.

CMN works in close collaboration with the United States Conference of Catholic Bishops andis a founding member of the Congregation of St. Joseph Mission Network.